Hello everybody, what do you think about this? Please can you share with your thoughts? Should we give money to beggars, why(not)? I have a dispute with my friend and I must prove her that we should give money to beggars. If you have any arguments about this topic, share with me please.

Tags: beggars

Views: 768

Replies to This Discussion

Hi
Yes,You should give money to him,because imagin that you are the beggars,you don't have money,family to help you and experiences for work .What will you do ?
Dear, Yousef, thank you for sharing.
Hi dear Aizhana!
Accoding to the Teachings,absolutly.
We must be compassionate and merciful to all creatures,and bless God,that we are not reduced to begging ourselves.If you can give a little money for people in need,do so.
I always give,if I can afford to.
"Be careful!When you do good things,don't do those things in front of people.Don't do those things for people to see you.If you do that,then you will have no reward from your Father in heaven.
When you give to poor people,don't announce,that you are giving.Don't do,like the hypocrites do.They blow trumpets before they give so that people will see them......So when you give to poor people,give very secretly.Don't let any person know,what you are doing.
Your giving should be done in secret.Your Father can see the things that are done in secret.And He will reward you."
/Matthew 6:1-6/

It is my opinion.
Hi, dear Monika, thank you for sharing your opinion, I surely will take it on note)
Hi Aizhana...!
Nice Discussion...
Acutally it depends...if the beggar is an old person(Around 50) then we should give the money...if the beggar is younger or childern we should not encourage them by giving money.... They can earn money in number of ways...just bcoz of lazy or some other thing those people are begging i believe...
Recently I saw in one of the newspaper that in one of the famous big city the bigger is earning 1000 rs per day..so he is earning more than the person who works... Bcoz of this kind of reasons also might lead them to beg..
So I request everyone dont give money to young beggars (around 25) and children...
Thanks,
Shilpa..,,
Make Someone smile and keep smililng...... It Costs nothing....
Yes,I agree with Shilpa too.Who is able to work,then do so!
I even heard of so a called "Begger maffia",poor people beg,and those evil people take away a half of their money...or so...very sad thing.
i do believe that we should give money to beggars because most of these people are a consequence of a system that put them aside, they don't have the same opportunities as we do, i mean, education, health, food, etc.etc. i live in argentina, where we have a lot of beggars,many people think it's not good giving them money because they say they should work or try to do something....but when u don't have anything, i mean, you are homeless, no job, no education, nothing...how can you improve in this world where money is needed for everything? at least with the money everybody gives them, they can get some food or something just to survive one more day, nothing else...i hope this message can help u!!!
hi shipashruti, yes, i think u are completly right on what you say about your people and mafi of poors, but how can u now if all of them, the beggars i mean, belong to that group or are really homeless? i think we should help them, if u can, if they are or not real beggars, it's up to them, everything in life goes and comes, there's a God and if they're cheating they'll have a consequences, but if they really need....

shilpashruti said:
Hi Aizhana...!
Nice Discussion...
Acutally it depends...if the beggar is an old person(Around 50) then we should give the money...if the beggar is younger or childern we should not encourage them by giving money.... They can earn money in number of ways...just bcoz of lazy or some other thing those people are begging i believe...
Recently I saw in one of the newspaper that in one of the famous big city the bigger is earning 1000 rs per day..so he is earning more than the person who works... Bcoz of this kind of reasons also might lead them to beg..
So I request everyone dont give money to young beggars (around 25) and children...
Thanks,
Shilpa..,,
Make Someone smile and keep smililng...... It Costs nothing....
Hi all
Actually,It was a good topic from the begining and your participating make the topic more good. ok I agree with vilma nora ravera ,because we don't know who is the right or not right .Also,I agree with the person who said they must encourge them for working ,but what is the ways for that . I mean we must encourge them for education,work and ......in first of all. After that we can blame them about anything like work ...
Hi friends, thank all of you for discussing, you are really helping me, I've known some new information from you=)). My dispute will be on next thursday, and if you have more ideas, you can write them, every comment will be helpful for me. Thanks a lot!!!
I don't know. But I give money to beggars
hi,
i don't think that we should give money to beggars, because there is always a work for anybody who wants to work..

RSS

© 2014   Created by Josef Essberger.

Badges  |  Report Member  |  Terms of Service